HFT May Account for Three Quarters of European Equity Orders
Esma study suggests, under certain approaches, HFT touches 76 percent of equity orders.
In the first part of its extended study of HFT, however, the regulator has run into a common roadblock in its approach, and its estimates vary wildly as a result. One way it has measured HFT activity ─ for which it monitored 100 stocks across multiple venues during May 2013 ─ has been the "flag" approach, in which firms that identify as pure HFT are tracked. The other method is more indirect, and measures order-to-trade ratios, as well as the lifetime of orders.
The distinction between the two is critical. While the first approach incorporates many of the market-making firms that utilize algorithms for HFT, and identify as such, it fails to incorporate HFT activity from other entities, such as sell-side investment banks. The second is therefore stock-specific rather than firm-specific, in that a bank may trade in a high-frequency manner one one name, while trading at high speed on another, and not necessarily at high frequency.
Under the flag approach, Esma has determined that HFT activity factors in to 24 percent of value traded, 30 percent for the number of trades, and 58 percent for the number of orders.
However, when the definition of HFT is loosened, the numbers increase starkly as they take into account the activities of other firms.
Using this approach, HFT now accounts for 43 percent of value traded, 49 percent for the number of trades, and 76 percent for the number of orders, according to Esma's analysis.
The report simply analyzes HFT activity, without making any determinations as to the quality of liquidity that HFT provides, which it says it will investigate in future installments.
Reactions on social media were mixed, with Johannah Ladd, secretary general of the Futures Industry Association's European Principal Traders Association saying that the variation in results proved that too tight a definition of HFT by regulators is risky.
ESMA study shows how hard it is for regulators to define HFT: if def too tight, it omits hefty #HFT activity of banks http://t.co/1r5GF96lx5
— Johannah Ladd (@JohannahLadd) December 18, 2014
Others also reinforced the difficulties with defining HFT from a regulatory perspective, such as IMC Financial Markets MD Remco Lenterman, a prominent supporter of HFT on Twitter.
ESMA study shows how fruitless and foolish regulatory efforts are to define HFT http://t.co/76uk3ACq7y
— Remco Lenterman (@RemcoLenterman) December 18, 2014
Writing on Fidessa's Regulation Matters blog, the vendor's senior regulatory adviser, Christian Voigt, says that while the numbers make for punchy headlines, the underlying methods behind the determinations differ from those previously supplied by Esma.
"Under its requirement to provide technical advice to the European Commission to specify the definition of HFT, Esma proposed two different options in the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II consultation paper; neither of those are applied in this particular study," he says. "With so many possible definitions, can Esma's most recent findings on the prevalence or otherwise of HFT have any practical meaning? Is it more a case of the results being driven by the underlying assumptions?"
Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.
To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@waterstechnology.com or view our subscription options here: http://subscriptions.waterstechnology.com/subscribe
You are currently unable to print this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. Printing this content is for the sole use of the Authorised User (named subscriber), as outlined in our terms and conditions - https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. Copying this content is for the sole use of the Authorised User (named subscriber), as outlined in our terms and conditions - https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
More on Trading Tech
Getting aggressive: Overbond uses AI to assess dealer axes
The fixed-income analytics specialist has developed a new tool to help buy-side firms decide if they’re getting a good price from their dealers.
TS Imagine integrates LTX’s pre-trade analytics tool
Users of the fixed-income EMS will now have access to LTX’s Liquidity Cloud tool, which provides a pre-trade score for the likelihood of trading success.
European exchanges turn to dark trading in battle for flow
The EU’s two biggest exchanges are launching dark pools this year. The apparent change in their stances on dark trading reflects a profound shift in equities markets.
After contentious Opra upgrades, vendors brace for a faster future
Upgrades to the datafeed widely used to gauge the current market price for options contracts went into effect in February after three separate delays, which market participants say were caused by persistent bandwidth issues at some important recipients.
The IMD Wrap: No more turf wars, or why CDOs should heed the Voice of the CTO
Max reviews how our recent Voice of the CTO series has implications for those beyond a firm’s technology function, and how communication and collaboration between tech, data, and leadership will deliver better results.
Dark horse: Deutsche Börse building dark pool
New functionality allowing exchange members to execute sweep trades comes hot on the heels of European rival Euronext launching its own dark pool.
Waters Wrap: The tough climb for startups
Anthony speaks with two seasoned technologists to better understand why startups have such a tough time getting banks and asset managers to sign on the dotted line.
European firms prime for lopsided settlement in North America and at home
With T+1 imminent in North America and increasingly likely to traverse the Atlantic, operations and trading professionals in Europe are fighting on two fronts.
Most read
- Women in Technology & Data Awards 2024: All the winners and why they won
- Witad Awards 2024: Above and beyond award (vendor)—Susan Bennett, Tradeweb
- Fighting FAIRR: Inside the bill aiming to keep AI and algos honest