• inside_market_data
  • inside_reference_data
  • buy_side_technology
  • sell_side_technology
michael-shashoua-waters
Michael Shashoua, editor, Inside Reference Data

Exponential Growth in Benchmark Data

  • Send
  • Comment
  • Send to Kindle

Greater competition among benchmark data providers, along with a willingness to look at other industries' data management practices, could spur innovation in financial reference data management

Benchmark and index data services are becoming much more competitive. This development is most evident in the reaction to Vanguard Group dropping MSCI as its provider due to high costs.

Research by consultancy Cutter Associates surveying its 200 member firms found that before this move by Vanguard, announced on October 2, firms would grumble about the costs of benchmark data, but would just suck it up and keep paying whatever was asked. Vanguard’s action could give the industry the backbone to demand more competitive pricing for benchmark data providers’ services.

In the providers’ defense, however, the complexity of benchmark and index data appears to have vastly increased over what it once was—and will continue to do so, as reported in an account of an exclusive WatersTechnology industry discussion. Data users are demanding rationalization of benchmark data, meaning checking what the benchmarks themselves are being based on and checking that benchmarks are operated within the correct risk limits. The proliferating numbers of securities that can be contained within a benchmark—as many as 13,000, as reported in our account—means processing benchmark data is also becoming more complex, as is correctly populating index data in users’ data management systems. To top this off, users want all this more sophisticated data daily or even intra-day.

In effect, firms—especially the buy side and fixed-income management firms that took part in the WatersTechnology discussion—have thrown down the gauntlet to data providers. Benchmark and index data providers will have to figure out how to provide much higher data quality, much faster, and for the same or lower costs.

The competitiveness of the benchmark data field just got exponentially greater. It will become harder for MSCI to rest on its laurels and simply call itself “the gold standard” if its users follow Vanguard’s lead and start defecting to competitors that provide data of equal or greater accuracy and quality, at lower cost.

With that in mind, it never hurts for the financial services industry to look to practices in other industries that could hold useful lessons. The ways social media data can be mined to answer questions in a range of fields could be applied to reference data management, as was related at the European Financial Information Summit earlier this fall. This month, we take a direct look at how the retail, telecommunications and energy industries perform data management and how their approaches can be models for data standardization and avoiding separate data silos.

The common theme in benchmark data’s growth and looking to other industries and fields for data management ideas is that the challenges of greater complexity and competition ought to spur more reference data innovations. I invite your thoughts on this at Michael.shashoua@incisivemedia.com or via our LinkedIn discussion group.

  • Send
  • Comment
  • Send to Kindle

More from Inside Reference Data

Sign-up for WatersTechnology email newsletters

Register for regular alerts to receive up-to-date news directly into your inbox

Related Articles

Latest Media

Events

Visitor comments Add your comment

  

Add your comment

We won't publish your address

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms & Conditions Your comment will be moderated before publication

Submit your comment

Winner's Announced: Inside Reference Data Awards 2014

View the winners...

The winners of the 12th annual Inside Market Data Awards 2014 and Inside Reference Data Awards 2014 were announced in New York on May 21, recognizing industry excellence within market data and reference data. To view the winners across the 31 categories click here.

imd-ird-awards-logo-2014

Training

Latest Whitepapers

waters-equinix-whitepaper-may2014

Tackling Teething Troubles: Examining the Current State of the OTC Derivatives Market

The over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives market is in the midst of a global regulatory restructure. Authorities in Europe, Asia and the US are currently...

eagle-whitepaper-jan2014

A data-centric approach to portfolio management

A fast, flexible and reliable investment decision-making process must be based on access to accurate and consistent information throughout an organization....