Regulation and Market Structure Dominate Thought at Sifma
Among the usual suspects for conference season ─ cloud, Big Data, as-a-service and other areas ─ market structure, or the future form thereof, is on most people's minds at this year's Sifma conference in New York.
It's not the most surprising revelation, given the regulatory backdrop to which the industry is operating in at the moment. In Europe, the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (Mifid) continues to exert its influence, while frustration threatens to boil over in the US at the ongoing lack of direction from regulators over the Dodd-Frank Act.
Both Sides
Being primarily European in both location and focus, it's been interesting for me to hear what people have been saying about continental regs from a US perspective. Take the oversight of central securities depositories (CSDs), for instance, and the drive toward T+2 in settlement cycles across Europe. One regulatory specialist from a well-established vendor I spoke to pointed to Europe as a test bed for what's happening in the States, and discussions over Target2Securities, the pan-continental settlement platform in development by the European Central Bank and others, also suggest that a pattern may be forming in Europe that's likely to be repeated in the US. Naturally, T+1 and even T+0 are continually mooted as possibilities, but given obstacles that even technology can't overcome, such as time zones, there's still a way to go on this. However, T+2 seems increasingly inevitable, and more importantly, can be accomplished with relative ease.
Structural Deficit
However, the most interesting and common points that I've heard raised between participants, vendors and analysts have been around what they see as the inevitable reformation of market structure. This is in specific reference to fixed-income markets, where Title VII provisions in the US, the establishment of swap execution facilities (SEFs), and the reorganization of capital markets affected thereby, are conversant topics.
Take SEFs in US treasuries, for instance. It's common knowledge that the sell-side market-makers are the gatekeepers for access to the papers offered. While retail investors can buy directly from web portals, it's the access and inventory supplied by them, to inter-dealer brokers, who in turn lend their memberships to the high-frequency traders (HFT), that makes it the most liquid fixed-income segment. Inter-dealer brokers can't afford to alienate the market-makers, of course, so attempting to reach the other branches of liquidity serviced by them ─ the institutional investors and the retail banks ─ is a faux pas of tremendous proportions. The traditional banks who act as market-makers, though, are highly regulated in what they can and can't do regarding the operation of SEFs, so the paradigm as it stands is looking likely to undergo significant transformation.
Other areas redefine the way in which traditional branches of the capital markets operate. The direct posting of margins and collateral from the buy side to central counterparties, the commissions now likely in advance of that, and the disallowance of asset rehypothecation are all leading to a rethink of not just structure in a market, but what instruments are even traded. Meanwhile, capital adequacy requirements on the part of sell-side institutions are forcing a reduction in the inventory held, in turn having ramifications on liquidity and other areas.
The Innovation Crunch
It's not hard to see that everyone is stretched, this year. Conferences in both London, and Sifma in New York, are noticeably sparser than in previous years. A conversation that I had with a representative from a major multinational connectivity company highlighted that everyone's budgets are shrinking, and that people are treading water.
One final point that came across quite strongly in discussions with hardware providers, software vendors and impromptu conversations on the floor, was on the lack of innovation within financial services technology of late. Whereas our discussions around Big Data, for instance, are just starting to turn to analysis and pro-activity as opposed to reactivity, conferences in different industries are yielding the real thought leadership and forward drives. One industry specialist used the example of datacenters to illustrate his point: Five years ago, pharma, defense and other sectors looked at financial services and analyzed how we went about technological innovation. Now, according to those sectors, finance has been left in the dust, he says.
So, what are the causes? Shrinking budgets are evident, of course, but big firms are still engaging in initiatives such as creating their own programming languages, private infrastructure, and intelligent aggregation of data, such as Markit's desktop platform for credit-default swaps and other areas commonly perceived as opaque. Vague regulation was the point it kept coming back to, and the lack of technicality on the part of said regulators - even if the Commodity Futures Trading Commission is making steps to change that.
One regulatory specialist from a well-established vendor I spoke to pointed to Europe as a test bed for what's happening in the States, and discussions over Target2Securities, the pan-continental settlement platform in development by the European Central Bank and others, also suggest that a pattern may be forming in Europe that's likely to be repeated in the US.
Brave New World
While it's not the rosiest time to be in financial services, it's also exciting. New technologies are driving reform and reaction, even if the innovation isn't on a par with other sectors. Regulation, while perceived as overbearing and inchoate, is driving the single most important reform of the market economy, possibly in history. Times are tough times, yes, but at Sifma 2012, they're also interesting.
Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.
To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@waterstechnology.com or view our subscription options here: http://subscriptions.waterstechnology.com/subscribe
You are currently unable to print this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. Printing this content is for the sole use of the Authorised User (named subscriber), as outlined in our terms and conditions - https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. Copying this content is for the sole use of the Authorised User (named subscriber), as outlined in our terms and conditions - https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
More on Regulation
Bank-led consortium takes aim at position reporting
Five banks, including Barclays, BNP Paribas, Goldman Sachs and HSBC, have joined forces to mitigate interpretation and implementation errors in position reporting disclosures.
Verafin launches genAI copilot for fincrime investigators
Features include document summarization and improved research tools.
Waters Wrap: Open source and storm clouds on the horizon
Regulators and politicians in America and Europe are increasingly concerned about AI—and, by extension, open-source development. Anthony says there are real reasons for concern.
DSB says industry is ready to meet UPI mandate ahead of deadline
The Unique Product Identifier will be required for certain OTC derivatives in the EU at the end of April, following US adoption in January.
‘Very careful thought’: T+1 will introduce costs, complexities for ETF traders
When the US moves to T+1 at the end of May 2024, firms trading ETFs will need to automate their workflows as much as possible to avoid "settlement misalignment" and additional costs.
Court case probes open-source licenses as movement stands at crossroads
The Software Freedom Conservancy’s lawsuit against TV-maker Vizio begins trial in California, raising questions about open-source licenses and the risks posed by adhering to them.
Waters Wavelength Podcast: Countdown to T+1
DTCC’s Val Wotton joins the podcast this week to discuss the impending move to T+1 in the US.
Consolidated tape hopefuls gear up for uncertain tender process
The bond tapes in the UK and EU are on track to be authorized in 2025. Prospective bidders for the role of provider must choose where to focus their efforts in anticipation of more regulatory clarity on the tender process.
Most read
- Northern Trust building internal cloud data ‘marketplace’
- Chris Edmonds takes the reins at ICE Fixed Income and Data Services
- Northern Trust: Improving transparency across the asset servicing market