Anthony looks at how combining cognitive technologies will yield the greatest benefits as machines and algorithms become more ubiquitous in the capital markets.
Scroll through the news and analysis stories on WatersTechnology—or on any other tech-focused media outlet, for that matter—and you’ll be bombarded with headlines about artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning (ML), robotic process automation (RPA), natural language processing (NLP) and cognitive computing, which doesn’t really have an acronym yet, but give it time and we’ll figure out something better than “CC”.
Each of these instruments and their derivatives can be discussed in a silo, but while each has its own specific use case, it’s perhaps more sensible to think of them in concert—a choir, if you will, rather than a capella.
A recently published report by consultancy McKinsey & Company, titled “Cognitive Technologies in the Capital Markets”, examines this transition, finding that these tools will create 20 to 30 percent in additional capacity to focus on higher-value activities, thanks to enhanced speed, accuracy, and efficiency.
“These individual technologies taken in isolation obviously have benefits, but the combination of [these tools] have had superior results,” says Jared Moon, a partner at McKinsey. “When firms think about automation at scale or applying technologies at scale, they’ll need a portfolio of these technologies.”
In a recent conversation with WatersTechnology, Michael McGovern, who heads up Brown Brothers Harriman’s global fintech operations, with a focus on incorporating new technologies, says that cognitive technologies, when used in unison, will yield the highest returns. But it’s also important to remember that while there’s a lot of hype regarding cognitive technologies, it’s still very early days from an implementation standpoint in the capital markets.
“Some of these capabilities are still emerging and some we have seen on trading floors for many years, but they’re making their way into more general business use. I think of them as tools in a toolbox,” he says. “We need to think smarter and in a deeper way about which use cases would be relevant, but there’s no panacea here. Cognitive [tech] is still the anamorphic principle as a marketing strategy, more than anything else.”
In its report, McKinsey compared eight banks and found that “those with the highest levels of digital execution saw front-office revenues per product increase by as much as eight times, while those with the highest level of post-trade digitization posted four times more trades per middle- and back-office [full-time employee] than the bank with the weakest digital resources.”
The report goes on to predict that cognitive technologies can generate additional capacity in the middle office of 25 percent while operations functions can be improved upon with capacity gains of about 33 percent.
“RPA and machine learning have high utility for the correction of standard instructions in the settlement and payments function,” notes the report. “Meanwhile, cognitive agents, smart workflows and [NLP] are most useful in client services, for example, for creating customized email responses.”
The breadth of areas that could be affected is breathtaking. By combining RPA, ML, NLP, cognitive agents and smart workflows, McKinsey says that there is high potential for impact in trade enrichment and allocation, product control, confirmations, settlements/payments, reconciliations, and client services; with moderate impact for T+0 activities like profit and loss, and risk checks, reporting and analysis, collateral and valuations, reference data management, and custodian and asset services. The only area where the consultancy found limited impact was for operations risk and control.
“We think that the change in the nature of the work and a higher-quality set of interactions and conversations are what will be transformative and where the value will be,” Moon says.
Not the Beginning of the End
McKinsey Global Research estimates that, out of 60 percent of all occupations in the capital markets, at least 30 percent of activities can be automated. In several media outlets, this estimate was mischaracterized to mean that machines could take over 30 percent of bank jobs, but this is a logical fallacy. Automating 30 percent of activities—generally low end, repetitive or administrative functions and not, necessarily, high-skilled jobs—will allow people in the middle and back office to focus on more important functions.
In fact, the report even states that the impact of technology does not necessarily “correlate directly with headcount reductions.” Something like RPA, McKinsey notes, reduces an individual’s workload by 10 to 20 percent, but that frees them up “to focus on higher-value activities such as research, idea generation and client relationship management.”
Machines will take over many jobs, and have undeniably started to put people out of work in the United States, but there are new jobs created by this revolution that cognitive technologies will bring to the fold. Humans will have to learn new skills, but the dystopian world that’s been predicted by some is largely skewed to fit a narrative at best, and at worst, only looks at one side of a coin.
And while cognitive technologies are impressive, we’re still far from a world run by bots. This is a progression. Today—and for the foreseeable future—machines will simply serve to augment what a human can do. Some traditionally working-class jobs that don’t require specialist skill sets will be lost, and it will be up to local communities, politicians, and schools to understand this sea change—a scary proposition, to be sure. But for the capital markets, machines will serve as augmentation vectors, rather than replacements, at least for the near term.
Eventually, more processes will be over taken by machines, but, again, new jobs will be created. New skills will have to be learned, sure, but this evolution is far from an overnight scenario. It’s on the horizon, but dawn—or perhaps more appropriately, dusk—is still a long way away.
Anthony and James examine some of the key themes that will be on display at the inaugural North American Innovation Summit.Subscribe to Weekly Wrap emails