Rob Daly: The Telltale Trade

Someone owes high-frequency traders everywhere an apology. After the events of the May 6 Flash Crash, almost everyone believed that high-frequency traders on the US cash equities markets were responsible for causing the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) to plummet nearly 1,000 points in a matter of minutes, and forcing approximately 300 issues to trade at stub-quote prices.
Thanks to the report recently released jointly by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the world knows that what caused the Flash Crash was in fact the complete opposite of the general consensus at the time of the event.
It didn’t start with nefarious plots by high-frequency traders that later infected the US futures markets. Instead, regulators attribute the day’s events to a trade by a fundamentals trader at asset manager Waddell & Reed, who tried to unload 75,000 E-Mini S&P 500 contracts in a space of 20 minutes using an unsophisticated volume-driven algorithm.
Once the trade hit an already skittish market—thanks to the fears about Greek sovereign debt—things began rolling downhill fast. High-frequency traders absorbed as much of the new liquidity as they could before clearing their books. However, it was too late, as the equities and exchange-traded fund (ETF) traders stepped back from their trading once they saw the imbalance between their prices and those of the E-Mini contracts. Trade internalizers also selectively started to route retail market orders to the exchanges rather than commit their own capital, further accelerating the market’s drop.
There are many lessons to learn from the SEC–CFTC report. One surprise is that the regulators did not take the opportunity to make further regulatory recommendations. How could they? Between the industry-wide circuit-breaker pilot program and the proposed consolidated audit trail (CAT), there is not much more they can do to eliminate future flash crashes.
The cause wasn’t a systemic issue; it simply was an inopportune trade made when the trader didn’t know the full depth of the market. It could have happened to anyone.
Yet, there is something to say about the wisdom of trying to push through such a large order in such a short amount of time using a fire-and-forget algorithm. According to the report, the sell algorithm did not take in account the price or timing of the E-Mini trades. It just looked for 9 percent of the transacted volume that occurred in the previous minute. In a down market, that algorithm would quickly lead to a major market imbalance.
The first thing that sprung to mind when I read that description was The Sorcerer’s Apprentice segment from Walt Disney’s Fantasia, where one well-meaning act cascades into a deluge of trouble.
I wonder how many risk management systems would have had the ability to identify the knock-on effects of such a trade. Judging from the fallout from May 6, not many. Then again, what responsibility does a trading firm have for the results of its trades if there was no premeditated malfeasance? Poor timing isn’t a crime.
Unless regulators plan to start licensing trading algorithms and their use, flash crashes will be the price the market pays for improved efficiency and interconnectedness. Hopefully the market-wide circuit-breakers strategy will work and arrest any future runaway markets.
Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.
To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@waterstechnology.com or view our subscription options here: https://subscriptions.waterstechnology.com/subscribe
You are currently unable to print this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@waterstechnology.com to find out more.
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (point 2.4), printing is limited to a single copy.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (clause 2.4), an Authorised User may only make one copy of the materials for their own personal use. You must also comply with the restrictions in clause 2.5.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@waterstechnology.com
More on Trading Tech
Agentic AI comes to Bloomberg Terminal via Anthropic protocol
The data giant’s ubiquitous terminal has been slowly opening up for years, but its latest enhancement represents a forward leap in what CTO Shawn Edwards calls, “the way we should talk to the world.”
M&G Investments braves cost headwinds in pursuit of AI
The UK asset manager’s AI ambitions started with the creation of a data lake to ensure high-quality data is being fed into models.
Asic probe piles pressure on ASX to deliver Chess replacement
But market insiders think late intervention by regulators could even slow down implementation.
Stakes raised for UK bond, EU derivatives tapes after Ediphy clinches win
The pressure is on for TransFICC, Etrading, Finbourne, and Propellant Digital, who are still vying to provide the UK’s fixed income consolidated tape after Esma awarded the EU’s tape to Ediphy and its partners.
Exchange M&A, US moratorium on AI regs dashed, Citi’s “fat-finger”-killer, and more
The Waters Cooler: Euronext-Athex, SIX-Aquis, Blue Ocean-Eventus, EDM Association, and more in this week’s news roundup.
LSEG officially sunsets Eikon
The exchange operator withdrew the platform from its product lineup this week.
Cloud Wars: Are EU and APAC firms really pining for homegrown options?
Waters Wrap: In the wake of tariffs and regional instability, there’s chatter about non-US firms lessening their dependency on the major hyperscalers. Anthony is not buying it.
Bloomberg, MTS expand portfolio trading to EGBs
The platform providers will follow Tradeweb with the extension of the popular credit protocol.